By Joel Preston / @cleccambodia
Following the tragedies in Bangladesh the regional garment industry is getting a lot of attention.
Before the events of the last few weeks, we would have said that building safety is not so much an issue in Cambodia. However, only hours after international brands signed onto the Bangladesh Building and Fire Safety Agreement, a building collapse at Cambodia’s Wing Star Shoes claimed the lives of at least two Cambodian garment workers and injured more than ten. Less than a week later, twenty-three garment workers, one of them a pregnant woman, were taken to hospital after a collapse at Cambodia’s Top World Garment.
This begs the question; where is the improvement in the life of a garment worker?
Since 2010, the Cambodian garment industry has been gripped by an epidemic of mass fainting. There were no recorded fatalities but in the last three years more than 4,000 garment workers have lost consciousness en masse during work. As the gap between wage and living expenses has risen with inflation, so have the reported incidents of mass fainting. In 2011 the ILO commissioned a report into specific incidents. The report found that “workers initially suffered from illnesses such as low-blood sugar (due to lack or caloric intake), heat strain, or exhaustion causing them to lose consciousness.”
Further, the report suggested that the majority of those affected suffered from a psychogenic illness “likely precipitated by a combination of physical (high heat, fatigue, lack of caloric intake to meet demands of the job) and psychological job stress (high pressure to work overtime and Sunday’s) and other life stresses (limited financial resources).”
Since at least 2010, this has been the reality for Cambodian garment workers – full time employment leading to malnutrition and psychogenic illness. Since at least 2010, Cambodian garment workers have had to reconcile the fact that:
“Today I may lose consciousness at work.”
That changed in 2012. On 20 February 2012, an unidentified male approached a group of around 6,000 workers protesting the poverty wages and exploitation that epitomize the Cambodian garment industry. That man shot three young women aged 18 to 23 for requesting a pay increase of 50 cents per day. That man was the District Governor, who later confessed to the triple shooting, yet was still not arrested.
Since that day Cambodian garment workers have had to reconcile the fact that:
“Today I could be shot.”
Now in 2013, Cambodian garment workers have to reconcile the building collapses of this month. They have to reconcile that “today at work I might lose their life.”
International brands invest millions in self regulated sustainability and responsibility initiatives but the sad truth is that we are now comparing garment industries based on who kills the least amount of people. Many people talk of the economic growth that the industry brings, but how inclusive is it? Where is the increase in those overcoming a non-adjusted poverty line in Cambodia, Bangladesh, or any other production country? This is merely clever marketing. Cambodian factory owners report annual turnover of up to US$16-18 million dollars. Further in 2012, the revenues of international brands H&M, GAP, Walmart, and Adidas were an amount almost 43 times Cambodia’s entire GDP. In contrast a Cambodian garment worker has a minimum wage of less US$75 a month and earns less than a self employed moto-taxi driver. The minimum wage is less than half the average cost of living in provinces where factories are located. Workers as young as 13 years old toil six to seven days a week, up to 16 hours per day just to cover expenses. They need to take loans to cover unexpected costs like doctor’s fees.
80-90% of these workers are employed under short term contracts that are perpetually renewed. If a garment worker asks questions about wage or maternity leave or freedom of association they will not receive another contract. Cambodian garment workers are hanging on by a thread – a combination of poverty wage, slave labor and the constant fear of not being able to provide for their impoverished families.
Pregnant women will work until they deliver as they are often denied maternity leave. This results in deaths on the delivery table, “do-it-yourself” abortion and suicide out of fear that infants will not survive during the three months it will take to resume work. Pregnant women will join strikes to demand increase in wage, maternity leave and milk for their infants, during which they are kicked and beaten by police. Trade union leaders and their members are also beaten, shot and criminalized for requesting that their basic needs are met.
What is frustrating is how easily this could be remedied. Increased wages would increase the price of garments less than a dollar per piece. Eliminating short term contracts and allowing space for trade unions costs nothing. The garment industry should be a revolving door for the impoverished but apparently people need cheap t-shirts and brands and governments need extortionate profits and kickbacks.
In its current format the Cambodian garment industry and the lives of those therein, are not sustainable. That should be a concern for everyone.
Joel Preston works for the Community Legal Education Center (CLEC) based in Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
The Multicultural Politic is Stephen Fry proof thanks to caching by WP Super Cache